P.J. McIntyre's Irish Pub: Cleveland Irish Pub Guide

If you are looking for a quaint Irish Pub nestled in a suburb of Cleveland, this is your kinda place. The inside has a magical Irish feeling. The “Pub” feel is definitely there, the only complaint I would have is how loud it gets. I has the Fish and Chips. The fish piece was large but a little too dry inside. Great coleslaw but I wouldn’t order the twisty fries again, not very good. We did start with the Artichoke Dip with the Boxty Chips and it was amazing, get this! My husband got the Boxty with Cornbeef. Thought it was pretty tasty but he was slightly disappointed. Overall, it was a fun experience.

Great Food, Great Service, and it's a pub :P We got the Ruben Egg Rolls, the Pot Roast Dinner, and a Burger. The Egg Rolls were huge, could almost have been a meal for 1 person. Super hot and came with a ton of 1,000 Island Dressing. Burger was perfectly cooked. And the Pot Roast Dinner tasted exactly how my Grandma used to make it. The service was great. A bartender/Manager was wiping tables as customers were leaving. Maggie took great care of us on our Anniversary. The place was clean, bright, and easy enough to talk to each other.

P.J. McIntyre’s Irish Pub delivers exactly what you want from a neighborhood pub—and then goes well beyond expectations. From the moment our group arrived, it was clear that this is a place that knows how to handle both food and atmosphere while keeping service top-notch. We came in with a group of seven and were impressed right away by the seating options. Whether you prefer reserved seating, walk-in tables, or hanging out in the bar area, P.J. McIntyre’s has it covered. Our reserved seating was ready on time, comfortable, and perfectly positioned to enjoy the football game playing on the TVs. Sports fans will appreciate the clear views and lively but not overwhelming energy—it’s social, not chaotic. The food was outstanding across the board. There truly is something for everyone on the menu, whether you’re in the mood for classic Irish pub fare or more familiar comfort foods. Appetizers came out hot, fresh, and generously portioned, making them perfect for sharing. Every entrée ordered at our table was met with enthusiastic approval, with no complaints or letdowns. Quality, flavor, and consistency were all clearly priorities in the kitchen. The beer selection deserves special recognition. P.J. McIntyre’s offers an impressive variety, catering to both casual drinkers and craft beer enthusiasts alike. From traditional Irish options to popular domestics and craft selections, everyone in our group found something they enjoyed. Drinks were poured well, served promptly, and stayed consistent throughout the evening. One of the most impressive aspects of the visit was the value. Our total bill came to about $200 for seven people, which included dinner, drinks, and appetizers. In today’s dining climate, that kind of pricing for the quality and quantity of food and drink is exceptional. It felt like we got more than our money’s worth without any sense of being rushed or upsold. The service tied everything together perfectly. Our server was attentive, friendly, and genuinely welcoming, checking in regularly without hovering. Orders were accurate, timing was spot-on, and any requests were handled quickly and professionally. It’s clear the staff takes pride in providing excellent customer service. Overall, P.J. McIntyre’s Irish Pub strikes the perfect balance between great food, a fun and comfortable atmosphere, excellent service, and outstanding value. Whether you’re stopping in to watch a game, enjoy a relaxed dinner with friends, or grab a few drinks at the bar, this place delivers on all fronts. Highly recommended, and definitely a spot we’ll be returning to again soon.

I live in Dublin and was looking for a good Guinness. Unfortunately probably one of the worst pours I've had. The head should not have bubbles and it was not creamy at all.

Absolutely amazing Irish pub! We came in town for the weekend looking for a fun place to let loose and this was it! Bartenders were on point. Drinks were great beer was cold. Fish and chips were amazing. I recommend this Irish pub to anybody who wants authentic Irish atmosphere and cold beer.